10 Most Reliable Used Cars In 2024

The time may have come for you to replace your old-faithful car. Due to the rising prices in everyday life though, a new car in 2024 maybe outside your budget at the moment and dreams of the 2024 Ford Mustang GT may have to be shelved for now. Second-hand cars make up a huge amount of the auto-market each year, and you may be tempted to buy yourself a decent second-hand car in 2024. When buying any car, quality has been reported by Statista to be one of the highest priorities for Americans. Plus, with those rising costs, the more time driving on the road and out of the garage is paramount!

We have gathered information and compiled a list of the most reliable second-hand cars of 2024 based on reliability ratings from JD Power. The cars listed are a mix of reliable sedans, compact cars, sports cars, and reliable luxury cars, so there is an option for a range of car segments for you to check out, dependent on what kind of second-hand car you want to buy.

The Secrets Behind Honda’s Bullet-Proof Reliability

Find out how Honda perfected the process of building some of the most reliable and dependable cars on the road

In compiling this article, we have cross-referenced information for vehicle reliability, maintenance, and pricing from sources like J.D. Power, Kelley Blue Book, RepairPal, Statitsa, CarEdge, and Consumer Reports to give you the most up-to-date and accurate information possible. Please note that we have ranked the following models based on the least reliable to the most reliable.

10 2019 Mini Cooper Hardtop

Reliability Score: 85/100

2019 Mini Cooper Hardtop In orange Posing in front of shop front on street
BMW Media

Oozing retro style, both inside and out, the 2019 Mini Cooper Hardtop is a fantastically reliable compact car that can be bought for an average second-hand price of $27,333.

Boasting large round dials, a driver-centric cabin, ample room for four people, and a 2.0-liter inline four powertrain that produces a reasonable 189 horsepower, the ’19 Cooper Hardtop is more than just a reliable choice, it is also a small car that can be used for some very economic driving. The 2019 Mini Cooper is cable of achieving 32 combined MPG, and is ideal for tight city driving due to its small size.


According to the NHTSA, there have been two recalls of the Mini Copper Hardtop, which was due to a steering gear tie rod which was at risk of breaking and a faulty crankshaft sensor which may cause the car to stall. Be sure to check that these parts have been replaced if you are interested in buying one of these retro little cars.

  • Average Yearly Maintenance Cost: $846 (RepairPal)
  • Est. Maintenance Cost During The First 10 Years: $6,754 (CarEdge)
  • Total Recalls: 2
  • Worst ES Year To Buy Used: 2007 – 2013

9 2020 Toyota Corolla

Reliability Score: 85/100

2020 Toyota Corolla In red Posing in front of houses on street

It is no surprise that Toyota has made it to the top 10 most reliable used cars of 2024 thanks to their awesome reliability track record. The 2020 Toyota Corolla compact sedan boasts a streamlined exterior, exudes modernity, is an economical drive, both in terms of combined MPG and maintenance costs, and showcases a refined interior to make your ride comfortable.

Not only is the Corolla a reliable second-hand car to buy in 2024 with a low average used price of $16,643, but it also features advanced safety features like Toyota Safety Sense to ensure peace of mind on the road.


Boasting a very low yearly maintenance cost and extremely low 10 year maintenance cost, the 2020 Corolla ticks a lot of boxes for a safe, economic, spacious and usable everyday car. There have been two recalls for the 2020 Toyota Corolla though. One for failing back-up lights, and the other for max-load text being rubbed off, increasing the risk of overloading the car and potentially causing a crash.

  • Average Yearly Maintenance Cost: $362 (RepairPal)
  • Est. Maintenance Cost During The First 10 Years: $2,220 (CarEdge)
  • Total Recalls: 2
  • Worst ES Year To Buy Used: 2014

8 2018 Toyota Camry

Reliability Score: 85/100

2018 Toyota Camry In blue Posing in park

Maybe not as modern as the 2025 Toyota Camry Hybrid, but, the 2018 Toyota Camry is a standout in the midsize sedan segment, thanks to its blend of performance, comfort, and reliability. There are multiple trim options that are powered by a range of engines, including a potent 3.5-liter V-6 that produces 301 horsepower.

The 2018 Camry can be bought for an average used price of $19,937 and comes equipped with lane departure warning as standard, four-wheel ABS, stability control, and traction control, so you can feel comfortable and safe on the road.


It is worth noting, though the reliability rating for the 2018 Toyota Camry is high, there have been a total of seven recalls for this car. Reasons range from a faulty fuel pump to loss of power assisted steering. Be sure to check out that everything has been repaired or seen to by a professional if you like the idea of buying a comfortable and powerful sedan with a very highly regarded background and reliability record.

  • Average Yearly Maintenance Cost: $388 (RepairPal)
  • Est. Maintenance Cost During The First 10 Years: $2,336 (CarEdge)
  • Total Recalls: 7
  • Worst ES Year To Buy Used: 2009


20 Most Reliable SUVs According To Consumer Reports

Be it a new or used car, reliability is an important metric to consider, and here’s how some of these latest SUVs fare for predicted reliability.

7 2021 Lexus IS

Reliability Score: 86/100

2021 Lexus IS In silver Posing against city building

If you are looking for luxury and reliability, Lexus is one of the best auto-manufacturers to go to. For years, they have been the epitome of both. The same can be said for the 2021 Lexus IS. This luxury compact features ample space for passengers, a modern infotainment system, and standard safety features such as blind spot assist, lane departure warning, and daytime running lights. With its refined exterior prowess, upscale cabin, and impressive array of features, the Lexus IS is a very luxury sedan that is available at a reasonably competitive average used price of $37,429.


According to Repair Pal, the 2021 Lexus IS has a lower average maintenance cost per year than other luxury mid-sized cars and a lower average yearly maintenance cost than all other car types as well. It also has a lower repair severity probability compared to all other cars as well. The probability of a repair being severe is 9% for the Lexus, whilst other car models have a 12% probability. If you are looking for something a little more luxury that will keep going, the 2021 Lexus IS could be a very smart choice.

  • Average Yearly Maintenance Cost: $543 (RepairPal)
  • Est. Maintenance Cost During The First 10 Years: $3,304 (CarEdge)
  • Total Recalls: 0
  • Worst ES Year To Buy Used: 2006 – 2009

6 2022 Kia Forte

Reliability Score: 87/100

2022 Kia Forte in gray Posing on mountain road
Kia Media

Boasting clean and cutting lines, a sporty image, a combined MPG of 35 MPG, plenty of standard infotainment features such as Apple and Android connectivity, and standard safety features, the 2022 Kia Forte does make for a good-looking, safe, and reliable sedan.

The 2024 Kia Forte is also this year’s high-range gas-powered car as well, so if you do want to keep driving a gas-powered and don’t mind spending that bit of extra money on a new car, the 2024 model is also a good choice for economical driving and reliability.


According to Repair Pal, the Forte has an average unscheduled garage visits of 0.2, so, you can be sure that you will be spending more time on the road rather than pondering what that knocking noise is. The top problem that has been complained about by owners is having no sound coming from the speakers. Yes, very annoying when you are cruising, but easily fixable and at least it isn’t a main component of the car.

  • Average Yearly Maintenance Cost: $451 (RepairPal)
  • Est. Maintenance Cost During The First 10 Years: $3,052 (CarEdge)
  • Total Recalls: 1
  • Worst ES Year To Buy Used: 2017

5 2021 BMW 4 Series

Reliability Score: 87/100

2021 BMW 4 Series In blue Posing in studio against white background
BMW Media

The 2021 BMW 4 Series boasts a captivating exterior design that blends sportiness with elegance. The bold front kidney grille makes a striking statement whilst being complemented by sleek LED headlights that exude modernity. The long hood and short overhangs enhance its dynamic profile, while the flowing lines along the body help to improve aerodynamics.

The frameless windows also add a touch of sophistication to this powerful and agressive-looking BMW series that boasts a range of powertrains from an inline-four, to a hybrid V-6 that kicks out a huge 382 horsepower.


Unfortunately, the yearly maintenance cost for the 2021 BMW 4 Series hasn’t been published by Repair Pal, but if you look at the maintenance costs over the first 10 years, it is considerably more than anything on the list so far. This is not necessarily due to it breaking down more, but probably due to BMW parts being more expensive than the likes of Toyota.

The recalls for the 2021 BMW 4 Series have been due to problems with the seat-belt audio chime, the passenger seat belts, and the rearview camera not displaying an image properly.

  • Average Yearly Maintenance Cost: Unpublished
  • Est. Maintenance Cost During The First 10 Years: $7,422 (CarEdge)
  • Total Recalls: 4
  • Worst ES Year To Buy Used: 2017

A 2000s V-8 Compact Sports Sedan That’s A Reliable Used Car Bargain

The 2008 Lexus IS F started the F performance brand for Lexus and still stands as a benchmark for reliable V-8 sports sedans

4 2019 Kia Rio

Reliability Score: 91/100

2019 Kia Rio in blue Posing in front of harbour
Kia Media

The 2019 Kia Rio is not only a deceptively large car inside, with 38.9-inches of front headroom, but it is also a car that, as standard, features a 7-inch infotainment touchscreen, Apple and Android connectivity, an advanced airbag system, rearview camera, and hill-start assist control. A second-hand 2019 Kia Rio can be bought for a very reasonable $13,998.

Maybe not on the same level as some of the cars with the best gas mileage for 2024, but, the Kia Rio can also achieve a very respectable combined MPG of 32 MPG. Not only is it cheap to buy, reliable, and full of great standard features, but it also gives you the chance to save some money on gas as well.


With a reliability ranking from JD Power of over 90, the 2019 Kia Rio seems to have it all when it comes to what is important to Americans when buying a car. Reasonably priced, quality and reliable, economical, and safe to drive. There has also only been one recall and that was due to the emergency trunk release failing. If that is corrected, the 2019 Kia Rio does become a remarkably cheap compact car to own and use on average.

  • Average Yearly Maintenance Cost: $434 (RepairPal)
  • Est. Maintenance Cost During The First 10 Years: $2,988 (CarEdge)
  • Total Recalls: 1
  • Worst ES Year To Buy Used: 2011

3 2021 Chrysler 300

Reliability Score: 92/100

2021 Chrysler 300 In white Posing on driveway

The 2021 Chrysler 300 combines a commanding powertrain with a timeless exterior style. Under the hood, you have the choice of a couple of robust engines, including a 3.6-liter V6 engine that produces 292 horsepower, or a 5.7-liter V8 engine that kicks out a massive 363 horsepower and 394 pound-feet of torque.

On the outside, the Chrysler 300 showcases a bold and sophisticated design, characterized by its distinctive front grille, LED headlights, and sculpted lines that exude luxury and presence on the road, making it a standout in the full-size sedan segment, even against the mostly overlooked, but still beautiful, Jaguar XJS.


The 2021 Chrysler 300 marks the first car on our list that hasn’t had a recall. That means it has the third-highest reliability rating, is still below average for yearly costs, is luxury, and it is powerful. Though it does have a higher average used price of $29,723, it is a lot of car that is sure to keep going and going.

  • Average Yearly Maintenance Cost: $631 (RepairPal)
  • Est. Maintenance Cost During The First 10 Years: $4,142 (CarEdge)
  • Total Recalls: 0
  • Worst ES Year To Buy Used: 2006

2 2019 Porsche 911

Reliability Score: 93/100

2019 Porsche 911 In red Posing on mountain road

According to Consumer Reports.org, Porsche has been named the 8th most reliable car manufacturer of 2023, so though it may come as a surprise for some, the 2019 Porsche 911 is the second most reliable used car for 2024.

Boasting the typical-of-Porsche sports cars low ride height, cutting lines, powerful powertrain, and a luxurious interior, it is a car that screams luxury and performance. The 2019 Porsche 911 has reliability and style but, with an average used price of $101,765, it is by far the most expensive car on our list and may defeat the point of a cheaper used option. But, for that price, you do get prestigious Porsche engineering, an extremely powerful powertrain, with the highest trim engine cranking out a monumental 690 horsepower, and some very impressive driving dynamics.


Though the 911 has had no recalls, a number of customers have complained about problems such as faults caused by an internal leak in the oil separator and coolant loss due to a leak at the coolant reservoir. Also, despite the high reliability rating, the average yearly costs are a lot higher than any other car on the list. Again, this is due to parts being more expensive, but more worryingly, also due to unscheduled repairs being more severe in more cases.

If you have checked out what to consider before buying a second-hand Porsche and the 2021 Porsche 911 is within budget, it can be a very reliable car that will no doubt put a grin on your face when hitting the gas.

  • Average Yearly Maintenance Cost: $1,072 (RepairPal)
  • Est. Maintenance Cost During The First 10 Years: $10,760 (CarEdge)
  • Total Recalls: 0
  • Worst ES Year To Buy Used: 2004


10 Most Reliable European Cars You Can’t Ignore

If you’ve always yearned for a European car but were put off by sub-par reliability, here are some of the most dependable models from across the pond

1 2020 Chevrolet Sonic

Reliability Score: 93/100

2020 Chevrolet Sonic In red Posing against office building

The most reliable used car for 2024 is the 2020 Chevrolet Sonic. With a reliability rating peaking just above the Porsche, the Kia Sonic has a lot of what you are looking for when buying a used car in 2024.

The average used price for the 2020 Chevrolet Sonic is a very low $13,102, it can achieve a combined MPG of 29 MPG, and it comes equipped with Apple and Android connectivity, four-wheel ABS, a post-collision safety system, and traction control. For the price, and the cheap running costs, the Chevrolet Sonic does offer a lot for a compact car.


Even though Chevrolet as an auto-manufacturer was ranked 20th out of 30 car brands for reliability by Consumer Reports.org, the 2020 Sonic has had no recalls, a low yearly maintenance cost, and according to Repair Pal, no reported problems at all.

Buying second-hand is generally cheaper than buying new, you also will lose less money on most mainstream cars when buying used in the long-run, and the engine is already broken in. If you can pick up a 2020 Chevrolet Sonic for a reasonable price, it may just be one of those cars that highlights the reasons that buying slightly used is better than buying new.

  • Average Yearly Maintenance Cost: $536 (RepairPal)
  • Est. Maintenance Cost During The First 10 Years: Unpublished
  • Total Recalls: 0
  • Worst ES Year To Buy Used: 2015

Source link

Leave a Comment

Ads Blocker Image Powered by Code Help Pro

Ads Blocker Detected!!!

We have detected that you are using extensions to block ads. Please support us by disabling these ads blocker.

Powered By
Best Wordpress Adblock Detecting Plugin | CHP Adblock